Superman Returns

Superman Returns
Original movie poster
Directed by	Bryan Singer
Produced by	Jon Peters Bryan Singer Chris Lee Thomas Tull
Written by	Screenplay: Michael Dougherty Dan Harris Story: Bryan Singer Michael Dougherty Dan Harris Comic Book: Jerry Siegel Joe Shuster
Starring	Brandon Routh Kate Bosworth Kevin Spacey James Marsden Eva Marie Saint Parker Posey Frank Langella
Music by	John Ottman Themes: John Williams
Cinematography	Newton Thomas Sigel
Editing by	John Ottman Elliot Graham
Distributed by	Warner Bros. Pictures
Release date(s)	June 28, 2006
Running time	154 min.
Country	United States
Language	English
Budget	$270 million [1]
Gross revenue	$391,081,192
Preceded by	Superman IV: The Quest for Peace
Official website
Allmovie profile
IMDb profile

Superman Returns is a 2006 Academy Award-nominated superhero film based on the fictional DC Comics character Superman. It was directed by Bryan Singer and stars Brandon Routh, Kate Bosworth and Kevin Spacey. The screenplay was written by Michael Dougherty and Dan Harris, based on a story by Singer, Harris and Dougherty.

The film is a relaunch of the Superman franchise that took more than a decade to get off the ground, and is the first Superman film since Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, made nineteen years earlier. Superman Returns revolves around Superman's return to Earth after a five-year absence. Director Bryan Singer has said that the continuity is "branching off from" elements of "the first two Superman films with Christopher Reeve,"^[2] which serve as, as he puts it, a "vague history."^[3] Although the film was met with negative fan reaction,^[4] the film received overall positive reviews and earned $391 million worldwide.

Plot

As the film begins, we learn that Superman (Brandon Routh) has been missing for five years, having traveled to where astronomers believed they had discovered the remains of Krypton. Thereafter Superman returns to Earth, crashing back into his adoptive mother's corn field in a craft like the one that delivered him to Earth when he was a baby. He returns to the The Daily Planet and his life as Clark Kent in Metropolis. There, he learns that Lois Lane (Kate Bosworth) has won the Pulitzer Prize for her article Why the World Doesn't Need Superman.

During Superman's absence, Lex Luthor (Kevin Spacey) has been released from prison. Upon his release, Lex marries a rich widow and obtains her fortune upon her death. Lex then travels to the Fortress of Solitude, steals Kryptonian crystals, and returns to Metropolis to experiment with a tiny fragment. The growing crystal causes a blackout by an electromagnetic pulse, interfering with the test flight of a new space shuttle tethered to a Boeing 777—a plane which Lois Lane is riding while covering the story. Clark flies into action as Superman and stops the plane from crashing onto a baseball field.

Superman (Brandon Routh) makes a rooftop visit to Lois Lane (Kate Bosworth) after returning to earth.

The world rejoices in Superman's return; but Lois is more concerned with the blackout. Clark later meets her fiancé Richard White (James Marsden), nephew of Daily Planet editor-in-chief Perry White, and their son, Jason. Clark is emotionally hurt when he overhears a conversation between Lois and Richard in which she says she never loved Superman. He therefore buries himself in his work, including halting a bank heist and saving Kitty (Parker Posey), Luthor's co-conspirator. While Kitty distracts Superman, Luthor steals Kryptonite from the Metropolis Museum of Natural History. Perry assigns Lois to interview Superman while Clark investigates the blackout. That night, Superman arrives at The Daily Planet and takes Lois for a flight, during which he apologizes for leaving her.

After this interview, Lois focuses her attention on the blackout again and ascertains its origin. She and Jason steal onto Luthor's ship, not realizing who owns it, and are captured. Luthor reveals to them his grand scheme of using one of the stolen Kryptonian crystals to grow a new continental landmass in the Northern Atlantic Ocean that will destroy much of Earth's existing continents, in the process killing billions of people and leaving him as the new landmass' owner. After seeing Jason, Luthor inquires as to who Jason's father really is; after Lois asserts that the father is Richard, he leaves to launch the crystal (now encased in green Kryptonite) into the sea. Under water, the crystal begins to create Luthor's new landmass. Lois faxes their co-ordinates to The Daily Planet and is attacked by a henchman. The henchman is hit by a piano, which seems to have been pushed at him by Jason; afterward, Lois and Jason are imprisoned in a galley. Luthor flies in his helicopter to the still forming continent. Meanwhile, Superman is attempting to minimize the destruction in Metropolis caused by the new landmass' growth when Richard arrives in a sea plane to rescue Lois and Jason. Superman soon arrives to help and then flies off to find Luthor.

Meeting Luthor, Superman discovers the landmass is filled with Kryptonite, which weakens him to the point that Luthor and his henchmen are able to beat him. Superman falls into the ocean, being stabbed with a shard of Kryptonite by Luthor. Lois makes Richard turn back to rescue Superman, whereupon she removes the Kryptonite from his back. Superman, after regaining his strength from the sun, lifts the landmass by putting layers of earth between him and the Kryptonite. Luthor and Kitty escape in their helicopter; Kitty, unwilling to let billions of people die, tosses away the crystals that Lex stole from the Fortress of Solitude. She and Luthor are stranded on a desert island when their helicopter runs out of fuel. Superman throws the landmass into space, but is weakened by the Kryptonite and crashes back to Earth. Doctors remove more Kryptonite from Superman's wound, but after it is removed they cannot penetrate his skin with their surgical tools. While Superman remains in a coma, Lois and Jason visit him at the hospital where Lois whispers a secret into Superman's ear.

Superman later awakens and flies to see Jason, reciting Jor-El's last speech to Jason as he slumbers. Lois starts writing another article, titled “Why the World Needs Superman". Superman reassures her that he is now back to stay, and flies off to low orbit, where he gazes down at the world.

Cast and characters

• Brandon Routh as Kal-El / Clark Kent / Superman
• Kate Bosworth as Lois Lane
• Kevin Spacey as Lex Luthor
• James Marsden as Richard White: Perry White's nephew and Lois' fiancé. He is a pilot who works at the Daily Planet under the request of his uncle.
• Parker Posey as Kitty Kowalski: Luthor's companion. While loyal to Luthor, she becomes highly distrustful of him during a plot to distract Superman from his main schemes that almost costs her life. After being saved by him Kitty develops a crush on the Man of Steel and even weeps when Luthor's thugs torture him on the new Krypton Island.
• Frank Langella as Perry White
• Sam Huntington as Jimmy Olsen: Clark's young friend and photographer at The Daily Planet, who is in desperate need of a good photo of Superman.
• Marlon Brando as Jor-El: Superman's deceased biological father, who knows him as Kal-El. He appears as a hologram to Luthor and whose voice is heard several times in the film (footage from the filming of Superman and Superman II were used to create his character for this film; see visual effects below).
• Tristan Lake Leabu as Jason White: Lois' four year-old son. He has asthma and appears very weak. It is revealed that he is the successor to Superman.
• Kal Penn, David Fabrizio and Vincent Stone as Stanford, Brutus and Grant: Lex Luthor's henchmen.
• Ian Roberts as Riley
• Eva Marie Saint as Martha Kent: Superman's adopted mother on Earth, who named him Clark Kent.
• Noel Neill as Gertrude Vanderworth: An elderly woman who signs away her fortune to Luthor, while on her death bed. (She portrayed Lois Lane in the 1950s TV series Adventures of Superman, and had a cameo role in the 1979 Superman movie.)
• Jack Larson as Bo the Bartender: A former boxer at the Ace O' Spades. (Larsen portrayed Jimmy Olsen in Adventures of Superman; he spends much of his screen time as "Bo" interacting with Sam Huntington as Olsen.)

Production

X-Men director Bryan Singer turned down directing a third X-Men film to direct Superman Returns. Because of his Academy Award-winning performance in Singer's film The Usual Suspects and friendship with the director, Kevin Spacey was immediately cast as Luthor.^[5] He in turn suggested Kate Bosworth, who played his wife, Sandra Dee, in the film Beyond the Sea, for Lois Lane, and she was hired after Singer saw her screen-test.^[6] Singer, unlike previous directors, stated his Superman, like Christopher Reeve, should be an unknown.^[7] After viewing hundreds of auditions and casting calls from directors previously attached to the project, he found a twenty-four year-old actor and former model from Iowa named Brandon Routh, whose frame and charisma suited the role of Superman; this actor's Midwestern roots and meekness seemed to fit Clark Kent's mild-mannered and bumbling persona, as well. Routh got the part after a meeting with Singer, spilling a drink on the director in the process, which a panicked Routh believed to have cost him the part. Nevertheless, Singer admitted the misfortune is what helped him choose Routh, because he visualized Clark's clumsiness in the young actor. In 2005, Brandon Routh was introduced for the first time to the media as the new Man of Steel.^[8] Hugh Laurie was cast as Perry White, but had to quit due to his role in the series House, being replaced by Frank Langella.^[9]

Bryan Singer (right) directs Kevin Spacey (center) and Brandon Routh (left) in front of a green screen set.

Rather than adapting an existing storyline, Singer chose to write a draft of an original story. Singer didn't want to do an origin movie, as he considers Superman to be a classic (as he had seen the film many times while filming X-Men), so he decided to do a return storyline. With his previous writers from X2, Dan Harris and Michael Dougherty, Singer created a script that was a semi-sequel to the original film with very little ties to Superman II and completely disregarding the events of Superman III and Superman IV: The Quest for Peace. His first draft included the character of General Zod, whom he wanted to be played by Jude Law, his first and only choice for the role. When Law turned down the part three times, Singer eliminated the character from the script. The most difficult challenge, he admits, was finding the obstacle that would be impossible for Superman to overcome: the passage of time and change. According to Singer, Lois' son Jason is a permanent reminder of this. While Superman's costume has undergone a variety of changes over the decades, the costume in this movie has been updated for the 21st century and clearly has modern and retro influences. The color scheme is darkened several shades so that bright primary colors are less visible and the material has a deep, webbed texture that is visible on close-up shots.^[10] The Superman chest emblem is now a smaller raised 3D-piece.^[10] At San Diego Comic Con 2005, Bryan Singer stated that the original silk-screened emblem looks like a billboard, while the new shield has an advanced alien look. The emblem itself is embossed with hundreds of smaller emblems.^[10][11]

The cape does not sport the large yellow and black emblem, and it now has a visible liner of a different material.^[10] The neckline of Superman's top has been changed from a wide scoop-neck to a crew-neck cut.^[10] The boots have also been changed, they are now a shorter, mid-calf length with a slightly rubbery appearance for the sole as well as the Superman emblem in varying sizes on the bottom.^[10] Finally, the belt and buckle are changed to include the addition of the Superman emblem.^[10] Several of these changes were inspired by the Superman costume from Superman cartoons produced by Fleischer Studios in the 1940s, that was inspired by the original Golden Age comics Superman created by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster.

Budget

The film initially was speculated as having a budget as high as US$260,000,000,^[12] which would have made it the most expensive film ever (as of August 2006). According to various articles, the development process had utilized "pay or play" contracts, meaning that those involved were paid even if production did not commence as planned. According to Variety, these development costs exceeded $40 million before Bryan Singer came aboard.^[13] On the site The-Numbers.com, Bryan Singer was quoted as saying the budget for Superman Returns was $250 million in late 2004.^[14] He later denied that figure.^[15] In February 2006, Warner Bros. had unofficially put the budget at $184 million, "factoring in tax breaks offered in Australia."^[16] In a July 2006 interview with Newsweek, Bryan Singer quoted the final production budget number as $204 million.^[1] On October 30, Variety reported that studio placed the cost at $209 million after factoring in tax rebates and incentives.^[17]

Filming

Shooting of Superman Returns began during February 2005 in Australia, on locations that included a farm outside of the regional town of Gunnedah in North West NSW and Newcastle and Sydney. Much of the filming took place in the city centre of Sydney, mostly in the York St area and near Wynyard Station as well as many other areas in Sydney.The part where Lois picks her son up from school was shot in Sydney Boys High School Other scenes were shot in various parts of the United States. The film was shot entirely on high-definition video using Panavision Genesis cameras. Singer said the first cut of the movie was 2 hours and 45 minutes.^[18]

Visual effects

A digital recreation of Marlon Brando in the film, as Jor-El.

Using footage from the original Superman film as a reference point, Marlon Brando was re-created using computer technology.^[19] In addition to the footage, photography was also scanned using a cyberscan and a lumispheric scan to re-create Brando's appearance.^[20] In June 2006, Rhythm and Hues, the studio that created the special effect, released a video detailing the process.^{[citation needed]} The video is available on the 2-Disc special edition DVD release of the film, but different music plays and the video ends with credits.

The opening credits for Superman Returns are presented in a deliberate recreation of the style used for Superman, again to the accompaniment of John Williams' theme music.^[21] However, the new graphics differ in several respects. They are of a duller shade of blue (changing to red for Brandon Routh's and Kate Bosworth's credits) and lack the 'soaring' sound effect that accompanies their predecessors. They are also designed using a taller typeface, and some letters are visibly conjoined into ligatures. In addition, whereas the originals change direction (zooming away from the viewer after the appearance of the 'S' symbol), the new ones consistently travel towards the audience. Because of the number of co-production credits that precede it, the 'S' symbol arrives slightly later on screen. The camera flies through space at breakneck speed throughout the entire sequence, following the path of Superman's return to Earth from Krypton. (In the 1978 film the opposite journey was depicted.) The sequence for Superman Returns was designed by Kyle Cooper.

At least a couple of scenes suggest past media interpretations of the Superman character. In one scene in downtown Metropolis, Superman holds a car over his head with the hood pointed downward at about 45 degrees, similar to the cover of the first Action Comics issue in 1938. The scene where Superman saves an out-of-control airplane and gently sets it down in a setting impossible to fly out of (a baseball stadium) echoes a scene from one of the Fleischer Superman cartoons, in which Superman sets a large, 8-engine airplane down in the middle of a city street, with the wings extending down side streets.

Brandon Routh, who actually has brown eyes, had to wear blue contact lenses to re-create Superman's blue eyes.

Promotion

The Superman Returns cast with members of the Red Bull Racing team

Warner Brothers promoted Superman Returns very heavily prior to its cinematic release. During production, Singer released a series of 'video diaries' on the internet at BlueTights.net, giving almost unprecedented up-to-date insight into the behind-the-scenes work being done on what would normally be a very secretive production. However, after 27 installments, the video diaries stopped for a while shortly before the teaser trailer debuted. On November 17, 2005, Warner Bros. released the teaser trailer,^[22] containing John Williams' music and Marlon Brando's dialogue from Superman. The main theatrical trailer premiered online on May 2, 2006.^[23] It appeared in theatres on May 5, 2006, along with prints of Mission: Impossible 3. On May 19, 2006 with UK prints of The Da Vinci Code, the studio released the film's international trailer. A second full version was issued with some prints of X-Men: The Last Stand on May 26, 2006. A third trailer appeared on the film's new official website in June, 2006.^[24] It also appeared online before the new site came on in the end of May.

Warner Bros rolled out an immense list of tie in products and companies which included General Mills, Burger King, Duracell, Pepsi, Doritos, Papa John's, 7-Eleven, and Colgate.^[25] and Warner Bros advertised the movie on the Red Bull Racing Formula One cars for the 2006 Monaco Grand Prix; David Coulthard managed to get the team's first podium that day as well. On the podium, Coulthard also wore a Superman cape in celebration of his achievement.^[26] NASCAR champion Jeff Gordon also sported the "Man of Steel" look by promoting the movie on his #24 Chevrolet Monte Carlo in the 2006 Pepsi 400 at Daytona International Speedway. Along similar lines, Troy Bayliss appeared in promotional 'Superman' leathers and sported a cape on the podium following a win and a 2nd place at the 2006 Brands Hatch Superbike World Championship round on his way to winning that year's championship.^[27] On May 11, 2006 Warner Bros began a campaign of nine different television commercials, and released eleven clips of Superman Returns through various websites midway through June. The iTunes Music Store also released an exclusive premiere scene, and was first made available on June 20, 2006.^[28]

Look, Up in the Sky: The Amazing Story of Superman, a documentary covering the history of the Superman franchise, was released just prior to the film. Along with input from Bryan Singer, the documentary contains commentary from other past and present actors, directors, writers, artists, and fans, and was narrated by Kevin Spacey.

Release

Superman Returns: An IMAX 3D Experience was released simultaneously in 111 IMAX format theatres worldwide, which (in some theaters) included approximately 26 minutes of specially converted 3D material. It is the first Hollywood live-action film to be released in this combined format.^[29][30]

The DVD release of Superman Returns was released on November 28, 2006. There are three versions available: a single-disc version, a 2-disc Special Edition, and an exclusive 3-Disc version available only through Circuit City. The third disc features the documentary "The Science of Superman."

The single-disc edition has no extra features, while the 2-disc edition has over 3 hours of bonus material, including deleted scenes and a behind-the-scenes documentary titled Requiem for Krypton: Making Superman Returns, created by Ludovico Technique.^[31][32] Requiem for Krypton, which accounts for nearly all of the three hours of bonus features (thereby making it actually longer than the film being profiled), ends with a blooper reel from the film, including outtakes from scenes not in the theatrical release of the film, culminating in a rare outtake featuring Marlon Brando.

Also released on that day was the 14-disc Superman Ultimate Collector's Edition. Alongside the four original Christopher Reeve films, it features Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut as well as Look, Up in the Sky: The Amazing Story of Superman and other documentaries. The Region 1 release of the Ultimate Collection set contains a 14th disc consisting of Singer's Internet video blog entries. All of those features were released individually the same day, as was Supergirl.

Superman Returns was also released on HD DVD (which features standard-def on the disc's opposite side) and Blu-ray Disc. These DVDs also have the bonus features found on the 2-disc edition. The film became the best-selling DVD of 2006 on Amazon.com in both the HD DVD and Blu-ray Disc formats.^[33]

It sold around 29.2 Million dvd in 2006, and another 10.2 Million in 2007, now in 2008 it has sold 2.3 Million.^{[citation needed]}

Reception

Superman Returns grossed $200,081,192 in the United States and an estimated $191 million internationally, taking in over $391 million worldwide by the time its theatrical run officially closed on November 2, 2006. It made $21,037,277 from its June 27, 2006 and June 28, 2006 screenings and $52 million in its first weekend. In its second weekend it was beaten at the box office by Disney's Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest in the U.S, but kept a fairly steady gross in the UK.^{[citation needed]}

The movie was well reviewed by many critics, receiving a "Certified Fresh" film ranking on Rotten Tomatoes, with 77% overall approval from critics, and a 73% from the "Cream of the Crop."^[34] The film also received a 72% on Metacritic.^[35]

Many critics gave the film particularly high praise. Empire gave the film five stars (out of five), and described it as "the finest popular entertainment since the Rings trilogy closed."^[36] David Ansen of Newsweek said, "Next to Singer's champagne, most recent superhero adventure movies are barely-sparkling cider."^[37] Other reviews said that Singer had done the Superman character proud, and that the whole cast had succeeded.^[38][39] Leonard Maltin commented on his website, "Bryan Singer has brought us a brand-new movie that celebrates the traditions of Superman in a movie that somehow still seems fresh. Superman Returns is completely absorbing and highly entertaining."^[40]

In contrast, Roger Ebert's reaction was more negative. Giving it 2 stars out of 4 he stated in his review for the Chicago Sun-Times, "This is a glum, lackluster movie in which even the big effects sequences seem dutiful instead of exhilarating."^[41] The New York Times labelled the movie "leaden,"^[42] while the San Francisco Chronicle observed that "Superman Returns finds no reason for being, other than that it's summer, and computer graphics have improved since the superhero days of Christopher Reeve."^[43]

Superman Returns was nominated for Best Visual Effects at the Academy Awards and BAFTA, losing both to Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest. Awards won by the film include Best Fantasy Film, Best Actor, Best Director, Best Writing and Best Music at the Saturn Awards,^[44] Best Superhero on Spike TV's Scream Awards, ^[45] and Best Male Newcomer at the 2007 Empire Awards for Brandon Routh.^[46]

Soundtrack

Main article: Superman Returns (soundtrack)

A soundtrack album assembled by composer John Ottman (also one of the film's editors) was released June 27, 2006 by Warner Sunset Records / Rhino Entertainment. It contained over 55 minutes of the original score as well as some Enhanced CD multimedia content, including two trailers and a "Behind the Scenes" piece on the recording of the score, which includes the film take on the main titles which is edited on this album with the end credits to create the "Superman March," which does not appear in its entirety in the film.

Legacy

Adaptations

DC Comics, Superman's publisher, released four prequel titles throughout June 2006 to tie in with the movie. The four 40-page editions served to explain the backstory to Superman Returns and are entitled Krypton to Earth (which reintroduces the origin from the 1978 Film, with Jor-El as the main protagonist), Ma Kent (in which Martha Kent recalls finding her son, his life growing up, and contemplates if she'll ever see him again), Lex Luthor (discussing Lex Luthor's time in jail, how he met Kitty and Gertrude Vanderworth (the old rich woman)) and Lois Lane (going over Lois' heartbreaking loss of the Man of Steel, her first meeting with Richard, and the birth of Jason).^[47] These comics were also released later in a bound edition called Superman Returns The Prequels.

DC Comics also released a comic adaptation of the movie written by Martin Pasko and illustrated by Matt Haley. The story in the adaptation only focuses on the core story, and does not have any mention of the possibility that Jason is the son of Superman. Nevertheless, the comic does include scenes from Superman's journey in Krypton, unreleased scenes shot for the movie. The novelization by Marv Wolfman was published by Warner Books on 1 June 2006.^[48] The novelization does not link Jason to Superman. Brutus is killed by Lois by pulling a bookcase down onto his head, snapping his neck; however, just like in the movie, Jason finds Superman near-drowning.

Reboot

Premise

Warner Bros. is currently planning to reboot the film series. With the financial and critical success of The Dark Knight, Warners said of the reboot Superman film, "We're going to try to go dark to the extent that the character allows it."^[49] Legendary Pictures president Thomas Tull said "Superman needs a powerful antagonist, a worthy opponent."^[50] Tull also wants to evoke Superman as an "angry God."^[51]

Production

Man of Steel

In February 2006, Warner Bros. announced a summer 2009 theatrical release date for a sequel to Superman Returns. Legendary Pictures was to co-finance Superman: Man of Steel 50/50 with the studio, with Bryan Singer directing.^[52] Gilbert Adler,^[53] Jon Peters,^[54] and Singer^[55] were set as producers with Chris Lee to executive produce.^[56] There were to be multiple villains,^[53] with Brainiac and Bizarro under consideration to be used.^[57] Singer planned to have more action sequences, with the "New Krypton" landmass that was floating in space at the end of Superman Returns to be part of the storyline.^[58] Superman was also going to fight "an enemy with real physical power."^[59]

Singer expressed interest filming some scenes in 3-D film,^[58] with post-production to take place in Hawaii.^[56] Man of Steel would have continued to use same musical themes established by John Williams in Superman.^[60] Brandon Routh was planning to return and improve his muscular physique once more.^[61] while Kate Bosworth was enthusiastic to return as Lois Lane.^[62] Kevin Spacey was set to portray Lex Luthor, and hoped to complete all of his scenes in a six-week block, as was done for Superman Returns.^[63] Sam Huntington and Frank Langella were to reprise Jimmy Olsen and Perry White because they were contracted for two sequels.^[64][65] Tristan Lake Leabu was also to return as Jason White.^[57] Parker Posey had offered to reprise Kitty Kowalski (even for a brief cameo appearance).^[66]

Singer dropped out of directing films such as Logan's Run and The Mayor on Castro Street in favor of Man of Steel.^[67] Warners and Legendary Pictures were disappointed by Superman Returns' theatrical box office, and were looking forward to a far lower budget for the sequel.^[68] Warner Bros. Pictures President Alan F. Horn explained, "I thought it was a very successful movie, but I think it should have done $500 million worldwide. We should have had perhaps a little more action to satisfy the young male crowd."^[69] $175 million was the maximum budget the studio was projecting.^[70]

In November 2006, work on the storyline was starting, with an eye to start filming in mid-2007.^[56] In March 2007, Singer halted Man of Steel in favor of Valkyrie.^[71] Filming was then set to begin in March 2008,^[72] while in April 2007, Singer, Michael Dougherty and Dan Harris were still working on the story, and Peters hoped to have a script by the end of the year. Peters planned pre-production to start in January —February 2008.^[54] Singer then announced filming would begin in mid-2008,^[53] while in October 2007, writers Michael Dougherty and Dan Harris left in favor of other career opportunities.^[73] The release date was then moved to 2010 because of the 2007–2008 Writers Guild of America strike.^[74] In March 2008 Singer said the film was in early development.^[75] Routh expected filming to begin in early 2009 for a 2010 release.^[76]

Reboot

In June 2008, Mark Millar claimed to have approached Warner Bros. on restarting the franchise, hoping for a 2011 release. A very well-known American action director asked Millar to "team up with him and his producer to make a pitch." Millar clarified his comments, "you have to wait and see if Bryan [Singer] is going to do any more. You can’t just go in there and nick a project off a guy. If Bryan ends up standing back and goes to move on and do something else, we’ll be in there like a shot."^[77]

In July 2008, Legendary Pictures and Warner Bros. were listening to various screenwriters to pitch their solutions for a second installment. Singer was still attached, while busy with post-production on Valkyrie.^[50] Comic book writers Grant Morrison, Geoff Johns, Mark Waid and Brad Meltzer also pitched their ideas for a reboot and gave their opinionated views on the film's alleged failure. Morrison stated, "I told them, it’s not that bad. Just treat Superman Returns as the Ang Lee Hulk." Waid said "The Incredible Hulk has proven the audience will forgive you and let you redo the franchise."^[78] Morrison's idea was similar to his work on All Star Superman, while Waid's was akin to Superman: Birthright.^[78]

In August 2008, Warner Bros. officially decided to reboot the film series. Studio executive Jeff Robinov plans to have the film released either by 2010 or 2011, explaining "Superman Returns didn't quite work as a film in the way that we wanted it to. It didn't position the character the way he needed to be positioned. Had Superman worked in 2006, we would have had a movie for Christmas of this year or 2009. Now the plan is just to reintroduce Superman without regard to a Batman and Superman movie at all."^[49]

See also

• Superman (film series)

References